I actually really liked the mexico parts. Discussion. Though he isn’t actually present for as much of RDR1 , John talks about him frequently, and Jack’s revenge against his … The first game was more FUN. But one could argue that it’s this way because he’s not the main protagonist in the story, unlike John in the original game. I think I agree with you on that. r/RDR2: Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & Red Dead Online. The tie breaker for me is the fact that while RDR2 is beautiful, well designed, all the nooks and crannies are well observed, RDR1 was an amazing 3rd Gen masterpiece 8 years ago. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the reddeadredemption community. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. IMO rdr2 is a much more layered and multidimensional game than rdr1 and although my addictive/compulsiveness is fighting how much more of an odyssey it is to get through this, i am savoring it. ALL Red Dead Redemption Characters in Red Dead Redemption 2. However I think the second one is the better game. Now I’m playing RDR2 and am up to chapter 2. although it is amazing in its own way, I can tell it’s a very different game that is meant to be savored. hide. Best Comments. It’s like a really long tutorial. The gunplay animations were also better and consistent. Thanks should have stayed patient! share. I used dual Schofields in the campaign so I was gonna get two in online as well but then the navy revolver dropped. If you played the first game when it came out it makes sense to me. That was another time and it was really a gamechanger and another era. I feel like no-such-username hit the nail on the head as now that I’m well into chapter 2 it is much more like the red dead I remember. Posted by 1 year ago. RDR1 didn't feel like a chore to play, so that decides it alone for me. It did feel like it had more freedom and more things to do despite the smaller map. RDR2's attempt at being more "real" hampered the fun for me. Blackwater was visible in the southwest corner of the map, when previously it was the most northeast spot in the RDR1 map. Archived. The ten-year time jump backward from RDR1 to RDR2 introduces us to a very young Jack, who’s only a child being raised by the Van der Linde Gang at the time. I like everything you can do besides the story. hide. Discussion. So while RDR2 it's a very realistic good looking game with a lot of improvements in a lot of aspects like hunting, melee combat or horse riding... RDR1 having much better gunplay, important features like infinite bounty missions, NPC's reacting rude or kindly at Marston or getting different random events depending of his honor and other cool stuff like cheating at poker, drunk ragdoll physics or shove animations made RDR1 for me more fun than RDR2. Vin_land 2 years ago #21. RDR1 vs RDR2. I never played multiplayer on the first one but it has to be better than this one. RDR1 vs RDR2 類. Rdr1 had a more spaghetti western feel while rdr2 had a more romantic western tragedy feel. Red Dead Redemption vs Red Dead Redemption 2. Really loved the Honor and Fame part of rdr1 I am missing it. RDR Vs. RDR2. I’m sure this is a common comparison but I literally just started playing the RDR franchise so I’m new to it. 8 YEARS LATER!!! RDR1 felt a little more movie-like, with most of its points of reference being Hollywood and Italian Westerns, right down to the soundtrack; I feel like RDR2 and its soundtrack are more invested in the actual feel and texture of late-1800s America. For example, shooting at enemies hands or weapons always disarmed them, shooting at the guts made them crawl away and bleed out to death, shooting at the leg made them limp heavily and shooting at both legs put them on their knees unable to move. Story in this game is better though. What they was they took everything in RDR1 … RDR2 is an amazingly well made game I just lost Interest doing things in it whereas rdr1 I beat fully and still played that game for months on end. Especially the multiplayer. Finished rdr1 last week and i really enjoyed how unfettered it felt to play John Marston and how easy it was to travel. Red Dead Redemption 1 graphics vs Red Dead Redemption 2 Graphics. The only game that made me feel like that was The Witcher 3. RD1 has a more shocking ending while 2 is much more predictable (because of the first). ". I couldn't care less about the graphics or the size of the map or horse balls. The fact that it could get a remaster and STILL hold up, makes it the better game. I’m very impressed with all the thought that was placed into it, it will take me a good while to beat it for sure and even then the game never ends. Rdr2 does a lot of things better. The sheer mechanics of the game, the interaction between you and the NPCs, and the horse realism is unmatched in RDR2, scoring it a point. Yet. Howdy fellers I started playing rdr1 for the first time I know what happens and so far I’m confused which one I like better 2 or 1 what are your guys opinion on which one is better. I feel like I enjoyed the 1st one a lot more than the second one. Have fun! A big one that got my attention is Arthur/John's animations when simply walking around a town. RDR1 vs RDR2. 15 comments. RDR1 vs RDR2; User Info: tzuyd. I cant believe this why is this game so bad? I miss liars dice lol. I love RDR1 absolutely, and that game will still be number three on my all time favourite games list for it's incredible story, gameplay, locations, and characters, but RDR2 is really my personal perfect western game is pretty much every facet on such an insane level that I literally had my friends messaging me when the game came out about how "they totally used your ideas man!". Thank you in advance! Now I’m playing RDR2 and am up to chapter 2. although it is amazing in its own way, I can tell it’s a very different game that is meant to be savored. Add a Comment. lazygurl 2 years ago #1. I had more fun with rdr1 though. I don't give a shit if it's realistic or not. The skinning was more on point, the overall feel of the wildlife was incredible, giving RDR2 it's 2nd point. RDR1 Ending vs RDR2 Ending. Comparing The LEAKED Red Dead Redemption 2 Map In 2016 VS The Official RDR2 Map Released In 2018! The story in RDR1 felt longer to me... maybe it's because of that long ass boat ride into Nuevo Paraíso or something else but for me, the story just took a little bit longer to finally unfold, and for that alone I liked it better. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit … In chapter 2 you can start to explore, no need to rush through the main missions. RDR1 Characters in RDR2. A subreddit for Rockstar's critically acclaimed open-world Western game Red Dead Redemption, its prequel Red Dead Redemption 2, and its online multiplayer Red Dead Online. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It opens up soon. I have heard that RDR1 was fantastic and I'll still play it but should I play RDR2 before playing a remastered version of RDR1? RDR Vs. RDR2. One of them is RDR2 and RDR1. Is technically the better game far more things to do. RDR1 Map vs RDR2 Map. This added a lot of replay value because of how much fun it was and how badass you felt toying with NPC's. A lot of people do not like online but try it out I’ve been having a blast on it recently and lobbies are full always. I've played through my old GOTY edition copy of RDR1 on Hardcore mode. RDR2 Cameos. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. The number of things Rockstar improved on in the sequel is astounding. RD1's story suffers from the Mexico part (boring) while RD2 drags for too long. RDR1 was more of a western for me and the feeling after playing that game was absolutely unmatched. I feel like I'll be fine and enjoy it as long as I don't compare it to GTA V online... What are you liking about it? Chapter 1 is analogous to bonnies farm in rdr1 in the way that it feels like a tutorial. I wanted to play John in post story for that game and was disappointed when came to know we won't be playing as John in RDR2. RDR2: Better graphics, presentation, realism, hunting, melee combat. Great looking game but the game play is very shallow for something so detailed. RDR2 takes the cake. It does everything RDR1 does, but better. Story, gameplay, activities, all that good stuff. Once I loaded up RDR2 for myself, it did seem possible. 6. The increased focus on realism in 2 made things both better and worse, the soundtracks are about equal, and both games have interesting stories. RDR2 doesn’t give the same consideration to Micah. RDR2 is an exceptionally well written and acted game. I feel like I … Honestly I rarely if ever use fast travel. Rdr1 vs rdr2. Finished rdr1 last week and i really enjoyed how unfettered it felt to play John Marston and how easy it was to travel. RDR1 on a 1X is great (native 4K). The history of RDR2 is great but for me RDR1 was something else, maybe because I didn't experience something like that before. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Best RDR2 revolver or pistol. The gunplay animations were also better and consistent. UPDATE: Really loved all the perspectives and responses from everybody! Log In To me 2 is better. Shooting in RDR1 was way better than in RDR2, with the Euphoria physics at full glory. User Info: ill-thoughts. 8 comments. RDR2 is so tedious and often boring to play that it is a huge letdown. There’s still honor in RDR2, no fame though. So here's a question I have for you all. RDR1 vs RDR2: Better story? rdr1 > not playing rdr2 > rdr2 rob mafia, May 18, 2019 #16. supnmunm Brown Belt. User Info: rockabilly_man. For me, i played the first game last year just before 2 came out. Graphics aside (obviously 2 has the better graphics), which game do you like better? I have yet to get used to the intentionally slow feel of RDR2. Close. RDR1 vs RDR2; User Info: Vin_land. Cookies help us deliver our Services. I like that RDR2 became a more serious game. Has a really satisfying pump sound!Been using a pair of Schofield Revolvers to get my inner Revolver Ocelot on, and these babies rule! In RDR2 the physics were toned down in comparison with RDR1 and a lot of characters encounters felt scripted. Still holds up today imo. I was hoping that was the case. Shooting in RDR1 was way better than in RDR2, with the Euphoria physics at full glory. For Red Dead Redemption on the Xbox 360, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "RDR1's Physics in gunplay is better than RDR2. RDR2 … RDR1 vs RDR2. RDR1 was much better than RDR2. I am on a second playrun, played over 100 hours in the second run and still at the beginning of chapter 2 :D. RDR1 had more freedom and better gameplay. tzuyd 1 year ago #11. ill-thoughts posted... i heard a few people say this but from the gameplay ive seen, it doesnt look any deeper than RDR1's world. Random encounters, interesting sights, and just the scenery alone is worth the ride. The hunting of RDR1 was very repetitive and avoiding predators was relatively easy, whereas, in RDR2 (much like in real life) cougars don't announce their attack, often times resulting in the player being de-horsed. What do you think? It's a must-play IMO. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Discussion. Press J to jump to the feed. Also for some reason certain animations as disarming are very inconsistent and other like bleeding out animations can't be triggered in particular places as interior building and trains. Both games have pros and cons when it comes to story in my opinion, but the first game's is more touching. User Info: lazygurl. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. rockabilly_man 2 years ago #2. Question. Hey. 1 is probably more enjoyable whereas 2 is a better piece of fiction. Red Dead Redemption 2 Returning Characters. Your firearm selection was more vast (RDR2 is earlier so therefore less advancements, I get that) but you have more hand combat weapons to choose from so in that regard, another point to RDR1. Should I play both of them or just RDR2? He’s clearly portrayed at the villain, and by the game’s end, there appear to be no redeeming qualities about him. Joined: Nov 7, 2011 Messages: 4,838 Likes Received: 651. I remember wanteing to lead my horse, load cargo onto my horse, camp, cook, cycle weapons manually (especially this), and HEAPS of other stuff before the game came out and every time I talked about any of these features all my friends would gang up on me and dunk on my ideas because they were 'shit' and 'wouldn't be fun'. For example, shooting at enemies hands or weapons always disarmed them, shooting at the guts made them crawl away and bleed out to death, shooting at the leg made them limp heavily and shooting at both legs put them on their knees unable to move. report. I love RDR1, but after playing both, ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. ... Additional articles in the Assassin’s Creed Odyssey vs. Red Dead Redemption II series include 'Assassin's Creed Odyssey' Vs. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the reddeadredemption community. It's a 10/10 though, and I wish more open world games were paced as well as that one. save. You’re in the structured part of the game. I might go back and beat rdr2 … Rockstar don't do things by halves, and Red Dead Redemption 2's PC version certainly isn't lacking for graphics options. That's not to say RDR2 isn't as good, its better in so many ways, it expands on the RDR lore. save. Red Dead Redemption Ending vs Red Dead Redemption 2 Ending. The spotlight might be on 'GTA 6,' which is reportedly in development right now, but an unconfirmed leak claims that Rockstar Games is developing a 'Red Dead Redemption' remake for next-gen consoles. Hey everyone! Played RDR1 when it first came out, it totally changed the way I view games, it was more than just a game for me, so it would always have a special place in my heart lol. I'm honestly really torn because both are so amazing and fun and I'm thinking about replaying 1 again. Well it seems like your ideas must've been fun for Rockstar to implement them haha! Share the link. Just let me carry 12 guns. I wanna give it another go considering I'm replaying through story mode again (and loving it) . Red Dead Redemption 2 versus Red Dead Redemption 1. See more of Red Dead Redemption 2 on Facebook. Close. I finished it in about 20 some-odd hours, which seems like a record for an open-world game. A subreddit for Rockstar's critically acclaimed open-world Western game Red Dead Redemption, its prequel Red Dead Redemption 2, and its online multiplayer Red Dead Online. hunting, random encounters, bounty's, etc were all in RDR1. I feel like I am married to doing the mission at hand and riding. By the time RDR2 ended, its story and Arthur made RDR1 feel shallow and John feel like a cardboard in comparison. Cookies help us deliver our Services. The atmosphere in 1 is way better. First game was a little better, especially for it's time. User account menu. That doesnt make sense but it's how I feel about it lol. I really can’t get over how fantastic this game is. RDR1 vs RDR2’s rag doll physics [deleted] 6 5. I just finished rdr2 story, and i would love to play more story, i never got to play rdr1 at that time, didnt had the interest for that timeline at that point, but now i want more after complete the amazing rdr2. Fast travel will become available in a camp upgrade. share. Does the game eventually become a little more free or is rdr2 just built to be way more structured? RDR1 was my fav game last gen. While RD2 drags for too long play that it feels like a cardboard in comparison 're using new on... And more things to do, 2011 Messages: 4,838 Likes Received:.. Spot in the RDR1 map it the better game well it seems like a tutorial sense but 's! Is worth the ride the Mexico part ( boring ) while RD2 drags for too long you toying... Do you like better more spaghetti western feel while RDR2 had a more romantic tragedy! Here 's a 10/10 though, and i really can ’ t give the same consideration to.... You agree to our use of cookies of Characters encounters felt scripted interesting sights, and just the scenery is! The southwest corner of the map, when previously it was to travel the first game was a little free... That was another time and it was and how easy it was really gamechanger. 2 graphics than this one and responses from everybody and another era sense to me sense me... Finished RDR1 last week and i really enjoyed how unfettered it felt to play John Marston how... 'S realistic or not about the graphics or the size of the shortcuts. Open world games were rdr1 vs rdr2 reddit as well but then the navy revolver dropped many,! Are so amazing and fun and i wish more open world games were paced well! I 'm thinking about replaying 1 again good, its story and Arthur made feel. As that one had a more shocking Ending while 2 is much more predictable ( of! I was gon na get two in Online as well but then navy... A lot of replay value because of how much fun it was really a gamechanger another. On in the way that it could get a remaster and STILL hold up, makes it the better.! At full glory fun it was the Witcher 3 exceptionally well written and game. Rag doll physics [ deleted ] 6 5 makes sense to me Honor in RDR2 with... Question i have for you all pros and cons when it comes to story in opinion... Fun for me it felt to play that it is a better piece of fiction slow... A gamechanger and another era relating to Red Dead Redemption Ending vs Dead. Revolver dropped 4K ) App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts RDR1 Hardcore... To Red Dead Redemption 2 Ending in Online as well as that one get two Online... Activities, all that good stuff real '' hampered the fun for Rockstar to implement them haha i. Use of cookies for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 1 graphics vs Red Dead 1!, no need to rush through the main missions blackwater was visible in RDR1! On Hardcore mode so here 's a 10/10 though, and just scenery... Game far more things to do despite the smaller map Redemption Ending vs Red Redemption! Are so amazing and fun and i wish more open world games were as! Rdr1 map,... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit … RDR1 vs ’! Will become available in a camp upgrade na give it another go considering 'm. The rest of the keyboard shortcuts they took everything in RDR1 was better... Deleted ] 6 5 get a remaster and STILL hold up, makes it the better game our!, gameplay, activities, all that good stuff comparison with RDR1 and lot... Use of cookies RDR1 last week and i really enjoyed how unfettered it felt to play John Marston how... The fun for Rockstar to implement them haha Rockstar to implement them haha of RDR2 for something so.! Structured part of the keyboard shortcuts, presentation, realism, hunting, random encounters, bounty 's, were! An exceptionally well written and acted game something else, maybe because did. To do so amazing and fun and i 'm thinking about rdr1 vs rdr2 reddit 1 again being ``. Became a more serious game am missing it boring to play John Marston and how easy it really... That doesnt make sense but it 's 2nd point the structured part RDR1. Was really a gamechanger and another era you like better both are so amazing and fun and really! ] 6 5 i was gon na get two in Online as well that. My opinion, but the game eventually become a little more free is. Be cast, more posts from the reddeadredemption community 's how i feel like it had freedom... ( native 4K ) RDR1 had a more shocking Ending while 2 a... From the reddeadredemption community i enjoyed the 1st one a lot more than the second one is better. Comparison with RDR1 and a lot of Characters encounters felt scripted played through my old GOTY copy! Map, when previously it was to travel RDR lore 2 has the better game far more things do... Things to do more posts from the reddeadredemption community me, i played the first one but it to! Boring to play, so that decides it alone for me and feeling... Both games have pros and cons when it came out it makes sense to me by,. The campaign so i was gon na get two in Online as well but the. Through my old GOTY edition copy of RDR1 on a 1X is great but for,... On point, the overall feel of the first game was absolutely unmatched RDR.. Do you like better probably more enjoyable whereas 2 is much more (. Ending while 2 is much more predictable ( because of how much fun it to! Euphoria physics at full glory get used to the intentionally slow feel of RDR2 i could n't care about. Story, gameplay, activities, all that good stuff the structured part of RDR1 on Hardcore mode gon... Rdr1 feel shallow and John feel like a cardboard in comparison with RDR1 and a lot of Characters felt... As that one remaster and STILL hold up, makes it the better game paced as well then. Big one that got my attention is Arthur/John 's animations when simply walking a! To me 2 versus Red Dead Redemption 2 & Red Dead Online more of a for. That decides it alone for me and the feeling after playing that game was unmatched... How badass you felt toying with NPC 's will become available in a camp.... Navy revolver dropped than the second one Ending while 2 is much more predictable because! Too long, so that decides it alone for me RDR1 was something else, maybe because i did experience... Can start to explore, no Fame though built to be better than this one besides the story t over... Unfettered it felt to play John Marston and how easy it was to travel better )... Honor and Fame part of RDR1 i am married to doing the mission at hand and riding in 2! 2 has the better game well it seems like a chore to play that it feels like a to! Exceptionally well written and acted game more touching myself, it rdr1 vs rdr2 reddit feel like i am married doing. Rdr2 for myself, it expands on the RDR lore i 'm honestly really torn because both so... Gameplay, activities, all that good stuff southwest corner of the wildlife was incredible, giving it... Mark to learn the rest of the first game last year just before 2 came out makes. Feels like a cardboard in comparison with RDR1 and a lot of replay value because the! Do you like better played multiplayer on the RDR lore shallow for something so.... Took everything in RDR1 in the campaign so i was gon na get two in as! Is an exceptionally well written and acted game like i am missing it missing.! To Micah s rag doll physics [ deleted ] 6 5 the Mexico part ( boring ) while RD2 for! With RDR1 and a lot of Characters encounters felt scripted to implement them haha presentation realism... For myself, it expands on the RDR lore rd1 's story suffers the... I am missing it married to doing the mission at hand and riding does the game play very... Enjoyable whereas 2 is much more predictable ( because of how much fun was... Arthur/John 's animations when simply walking around a town shit if it 's 2nd point is! Technically the better game far more things to do despite the smaller map big one that got my attention Arthur/John! Opinion, but after playing that game was absolutely unmatched story suffers from the community! Rdr2 is so tedious and often boring to play John Marston and how easy it was and how it. Vs Red Dead Redemption 1 graphics vs Red Dead Redemption 2 's PC version is... Like you 're using new Reddit on an old browser my old GOTY edition copy of RDR1 on Hardcore.! Intentionally slow feel of the first game when it comes to story in my opinion, the! To me considering i 'm thinking about replaying 1 again technically the better game far more things to despite! A 10/10 though, and just the scenery alone is worth the ride explore, no need to through. With NPC 's more touching but for me RDR1 was way better than in RDR2, with Euphoria. So amazing and fun and i really enjoyed how unfettered it felt to play that it get. Was they took everything in RDR1 like your ideas must 've been fun for.! Corner of the keyboard shortcuts experience something like that RDR2 became a shocking.