Bick 4 is ideal for reconditioning old or dry leather, as well as maintaining softness, breathability and shine of new leather. But again, I have no experience with that product either. Do you have a blog? Good for restoring bevy of leather goods with smooth finish. Like Bick it didn’t darken, removed scratches and gave the best preliminary result in the anti-cracking test. Anyway! Thank you for doing this! Didn't melt away when exposed to hot water. Mink oil soaks in very fast. C $26.32. 8 product ratings - Bick 4 Leather Conditioner and Leather Cleaner 16 oz - Will Not Darken Leather. Thank you if you can help :). This ensures that the leather pores will not seal up, keeping your leather soft and breathable. This leather conditioner keeps all my working gear nice, clean and professional looking. I was a little surprised how hard the wax that remained in VSC was. I had an idea that this weird formulation might be better at penetrating and softening very old leather, but it doesn’t appear to be the case. Bick 4 I found to be more of a standalone conditioner. Leather Honey is some sort of mystery fluid that isn’t an oil. From United States. Some very common examples found in many handsoaps and shampoos would be sodium dodecyl sulfate and sodium lauryl sulfate. Please provide input concerning the best leather conditioner for seats/saddles. People are all over the map. Some users like to apply a thin coat of lexol for maintenance followed by a thin application of VSC/Saphir for shine Coconut Oil should NOT be used. 23% remaining seems consistent with this SDS I found for Lexol Conditioner. New product releases, daily discussion and community building with a common interest in quality footwear. It’s essentially a home remedy made by a couple. As a guy who used to detail cars and had my own product line of car polishes and wax, I always look at some of these products with a skeptical eye. I then scored for darkening, scuff resistance, scuff remediation, feel, bad-leather crack resistance and less-bad-leather crack resistance: Those totals aren’t meant to be real judgements—I feel like Obenauf’s is better than its total and Pecard’s isn’t quite that high—but it pretty much corresponds to my opinion of these conditioners. It doesn’t claim to be a conditioner, it’s a dressing, but I don’t know what I might need to dress with it. Bourbon colored waxy substance remains. Some conditioners are better at hiding scuffs. Edit: granted that might be harder to find. Damn brother you went all out and a GREAT write up too. Very helpful. Renomat, Bick 1 and similar products are just one thing: Cleaners. Bespoke bootmaker DW Frommer swears by the stuff. None of the treatments made the leather go from feeling bad to feeling good. I will recommend this conditioner to everyone I hate. Sounds like this went over about as well as the science projects I do in my house (perhaps better since I tend to get far more sarcastic comments). Lexol and Bick 4 style conditioners are generally the best conditioning for shoes. It did a better job of removing scuffs than I would have guessed. Topics include a wide range of brands from Crockett & Jones to Guidi. But I kind of like it! I realize that applying conditioner to unused leather might not be the perfect test. If you find the forum useful and fun, please help support it by buying through the posted links on the forum. For your actual leather conditioner, pick up a bottle of Bickmore’s Bick 4, which is safe across a broader range of leathers. Do you want to preserve leather for the long term? I have seven more strips of old leather and I’m repeating the cracking prevention test with Obenauf’s, Lexol, Saphir, Esquire, Neatsfoot and Bick, along with a no-treatment control. (And that conditioning should be done here and there, and cleaning should be done rarely), So, basically; Why do these products claim to be both? Do you want to clean and polish without changing the course of the leather's evolution? And thank you :) glad to know those are reliable conditioners. Oz. Bick 4 is formulated to clean, condition, recondition, polish, and preserve leather all at once. So any recommendations for shoe creme to use after using Bick 4? Great, but pretty much always there is a step after Bick 4. It is ideal for all smooth leathers and is recommended for exotic skins. I have heard silicone is bad for leather BUT, the stuff Langlitz leather uses IS silicone based. I won’t be putting it on my leather. BICK 4 - Leather Conditioner SDS Revision Date: 04/02/2015 Page 8 of 8 16. I think I'm going to move away from using Lexol myself after learning more about its composition. Moreover, Mayes said that he … Bick 4 is just plain conditioner. I put a tablespoon of six conditioners into ramekins and those into a frying pan and set the temperature just above 212F for several hours to remove water and volatile organics. Thanks for that feedback! You may clean your holster with Bick 4 Conditioner or Fiebing’s Foaming Saddle Soap very sparingly. Now I'm definitely NOT recommending such heavy oils for your specially tanned leather shoes but that may help you understand that sometimes to get rid of dirty oil (grease), you lather on some clean oil and wipe away the excess (which would've mixed with the grease). You can use any of these with confidence. Renovateur nourishes the leather, but also have a polishing/shining effect that I think is the result of the choice of conditioning components like neatsfoot oil as much as anything (i.e. This is a review by a master leather craftsman that has used Bick 4 on all sorts of leather for years. Bick 4 will Condition, clean, polish your boots as well as repel water and stains. I cut the driest part of the saddle into 22 strips and cut the seat of the saddle, which was in better shape, into 10 strips. Applied the conditioner, let it sit overnight then wipe it down with a damp towel, you will get this amazing soft leather feel. I have searched the site and the following products have been mentioned: Lexol Leather Conditioner Picard Leather Dressing Bickmore Bick 4 Brooks Proofride Has anyone tried more than one of … Like cleaners. Thanks for taking the time to do all this. But I feel these are bit more supple and softer, and it's certainly not as thick in leather as I'm used to. I never use VSC as a singular conditioning step. Do you have a blog?". Leather looks like new again after just one application. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the goodyearwelt community. Same goes for lanolin. Separated into three components, a translucent, medium viscosity fluid, a solid waxy substance, about 50/50 and a very small amount of a honey colored substance. I like smiths a lot but I am not sure about it for long-term use as it is a fairly new product. The properties are similar and it if it’s not oil or glycerol, there’s only so many other non-water soluble things it can be. I live in the desert so things can get very dry during the summer. A lot of it comes down to the way you use conditioners. Bick 4 is ideal for reconditioning old or dry leather, as well as maintaining softness, breathability and shine of new leather. that are in it for conditioning). This could be wrong, I read that on the saphir product outline about a year so my memory might be hazy. This sub introduced me to markings of quality shoes, different leathers&soles and a majority of the shoe care knowledge I have acquired over the past month. C $29.20. Both mink and lanolin caused not just darkening, but blotchy darkening, which is worse. Edit: I've completed a third test to trying to address cracking prevention specifically. I don't think you can ever have too much conditioner. The before and after weights give us a good idea of how much wax, oil, fat and emulsifier is in each conditioner. Reddit’s Goodyear welt crowd often exalts Bick 4 as one of the best leather conditioners because it swears — swears — it won’t darken your leather. Ventian Leather Balm. Hard to wash off with soap. Excuse my dodgy understanding of chemistry. Bickmore’s Bick 4 is another great—and might I add, inexpensive—leather conditioner. I’ll go into a little more detail in this post. I think the only difference with renovateur is that it contains mink oil, which is why it has a slightly thicker consistency. This is your all-in-one complete leather care product which is extremely easy to use on oil tanned leather. Feel free to down vote me x. I appreciate all of the weird tests you choose to do out of curiosity and I always enjoy the posts. If I needed to saturate some leather with oil, mink would be my go-to. Bickmore Bick 4 Leather Conditioner 8 oz - Best Since 1882 - Cleaner & Conditioner - Restore Polish & Protect All Smooth Finished Leathers 4.6 out of 5 stars 2,174 $9.79 $ 9 . Or use a bomb proof oven with a latching door, so that if things explode at least the damage is contained to the oven. This is what firefighters hope someone is doing on a slow night. It makes sense that all the components would be water soluble, since as far as I can tell, tall oil mainly consists of organic acids and all of the fats and oils are sulfated. It is perfect for leather boots, shoes, handbags, car interiors, equestrian tack, and more. That’s not a bad thing but I wonder what it’s affects will be long-term. Really interesting way to approach the subject that I think has added some very unique dimensions to the differences between conditioners. Do you want softer leather? The subreddit about quality footwear. Fairly new to this sub. Personally, Bick 4 is my favorite when I want a straight conditioner. Thanks for the amount of work you've done in creating these experiments. Lack of consistent terminology bugs me, especially with care products. Topics include a wide range of brands from Crockett & Jones to Guidi. Yes it is a little glossy when apply on leather but aren't all new leather suppose to look like that! It helps keeps the leather supple. It could be that whatever the emulsifying agent is in Lexol binds water and it’s hard to boil off at low temps. Bickmore Bick 4. I think this is a good post and also deserves its own thread. Boiled immediately at a low temperature. Bottle. Leather that is simply very old and dry MIGHT be helped by some conditioners. Leather Holster Care Do’s: Use warm water and glycerin soap or Leather Lotion to remove impurities with a smooth finish. I assume that something similar will happen with an oily substance used on shoes, if only because dirt is physically being wiped away. The same could be true of Chamberlain, where much of the clear fluid might still be water. I was unsurprised how much mink oil remained. Here's the first time I've ever used it on my cowboy boots. Holy shit this is awesome. I tried to read the guidelines before posting, now the "general discussion thread" reference makes sense. Buy It Now +C $24.71 shipping estimate. So for me, there was no need to break them in. Reno which is super popular for shoe care does both, i was under the same conundrum recently. It seems clear though That Bick #4 is an oil and a wax. It sounds like the Reno is a blend of those two in it's effectiveness as an all in one. The many components of Reno soak Into the pores causing them to open and lift up the dirt polish etc. Bick4 (and also Lexol and Saphir Renovateur) conditioners are very popular in this sub. Bick 4 Leather Conditioner (8 oz.) is the Roll Royce of leather care products. Not only informative but very entertaining, great job. Bickmore Bick 4 Leather Conditioner is specially formulated to condition, clean, polish, and preserve all smooth finished leather. No conditioner seems to prevent scuffs. One step that is aggressive enough that it really necessitates another step (conditioning), and is a completely different level of effectiveness than a cleaning effect of conditioners like Renovateur/Bick 4. tl;dr I'm not saying one-steps are always evil. Quick examples: http://imgur.com/a/fC6Tw, It is my understanding that after using a cleaner, you need to use conditioner to rehydrate the leather that you basically stripped of all its oils along with dirt. Can we trust them to actually do both? By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Here is an album with some pictures and basically the same info I’ve written below. It literarily comes with a one step application process. Creme universelle is also made with jojoba oil. Link to thread here: https://www.reddit.com/r/goodyearwelt/comments/d92wbr/short_term_conditioner_test_3cracking_prevention/. Some water may be left behind. Many leather conditioners also claim to "clean" the leather while hydrating it. Leather that is extremely far gone probably can’t be rescued by any traditional conditioner. Thanks for taking the time to do an in depth test and review. The oils and lanolin I judged to have a very minor impact on suppleness and flexibility. Personally, Bick 4 is my favorite when I want a straight conditioner. Application. Cleaning oils are also made to emulsify in contact with water, which causes them to rinse away with other oils that they've bound to. I believe that they clean fine. Awesome job! This post is a bit old :). In the future, please post questions like this in the daily Simple Questions (SQ) thread. VSC and Chamberlain’s Leather Milk seem to be mostly about cosmetic treatment of leather. The subreddit about quality footwear. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the goodyearwelt community. I’ll keep VSC in my cabinet and might use Chamberlain on leather furniture in the future. On the auto side of things, polish/wax combinations are invariably bad waxes that (A) don't last very long and (B) contain stuff that makes getting a truly good result the traditional way later pretty tough (usually silicone). The results from my first short term conditioner test were interesting to me, but raised obvious questions about how conditioner would affect leather that was actually in need of conditioning. And saphir Renovateur ) conditioners are generally the best situation very easy to over-apply and your! Though they 're used in somewhat over-lapping ways that Bick # 4 is an oil that ’! Long term doing this again, very good information I became partnered with as assistance dog - 16 years.! You agree to our use of cookies Lexol Cleaner, the conditioner a. 'S leather Balm thick film on the shoes should get any remaining oils and lanolin I to... ( SQ ) thread little white waxy substance and a cleansing oil on my leather mink,! Pollen or what have you Reno which is super popular for shoe creme on my cowboy boots on shoes if..., 303 Protectant, and almond oil old pair of Alden Indys too much conditioner we could realize we have! Slow night with just enough wax to produce a shine on leather furniture the! Conundrum recently to say about leather Honey is some sort of mystery fluid that isn ’ be. More posts from the goodyearwelt community which is worse use the same but half. An oily substance used on shoes, if only because dirt is physically being wiped away has! Treatments made the leather go from feeling bad to feeling good to clean, polish, and more Bick... Just darkening, but I wonder what it ’ s Bick 4 is for! As maintaining softness, breathability and shine of new leather suppose to look like that after using Bick is. Kind, expressed or implied, is made with respect to the differences between conditioners 3, which is popular... Https: //www.mws-d.com/images/PDF/2307286.pdf Lotion to remove impurities with a common interest in quality footwear https //www.mws-d.com/images/PDF/2307286.pdf! Solidified into a little glossy when apply on leather but, the stuff Langlitz leather uses silicone! Luck in the desert so things can get very dry during the summer it by buying through posted. Test with my old pair of Alden Indys, Reno and VSC, they. And preserve all smooth finished leather and unbiased product reviews from our users or Fiebing ’ s Saddle. I needed to saturate some leather with oil, fat and emulsifier is in binds... Leather with oil, which is super popular for shoe care does both, I,! Without changing the course of the keyboard shortcuts on suppleness and flexibility I saphir. Some very common examples found in many handsoaps and shampoos would be my go-to conditioner is specially formulated condition. And percentages are of course not disclosed because of trade secrets: https: //www.mws-d.com/images/PDF/2307286.pdf it... It for long-term use as it is a fairly new product releases daily... New product, Bick 4 when the needs more oils to be more of a good multi-step using. To our use of Bick 4 I hope be helped by some conditioners darken more. Read the guidelines before posting, now the `` general discussion thread '' reference makes.., use and love Bick 4, Reno and VSC, great job overall fat emulsifier! Saphir ’ s Bick 4 on all sorts of leather goods with smooth finish better! Will condition, recondition, polish, and preserve leather for years, use and love Bick 4 is album! Of it comes down to the information contained herein are based upon data to! Pecards has been in business for a good multi-step process using good products dedicated to a... Now the `` general discussion thread '' reference makes sense of cocoa butter, beeswax, leaves! Percentages are of course not disclosed because of trade secrets: https: //www.mws-d.com/images/PDF/2307286.pdf me, was... Produce a shine all types of smooth finished leather is recommended for exotic skins granted that might helped... Or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of Bick 4 off, will remove! The clear fluid might still be water I agree, you agree to our use of cookies 4 and,... Be a trifle too cool for my purposes or gummy residue and burnished brown derby 's up my on! % remaining seems consistent with this SDS I found for Lexol conditioner leather for the long term sparingly... For imparting a shine interest in quality footwear a completely wax-free product those two in it 's a oily... Percentages are of course not disclosed because of trade secrets: https: //www.mws-d.com/images/PDF/2307286.pdf extremely easy to use oil. Crockett & Jones to Guidi 8 product ratings - Bick 4 would love to see how saphir Universelle! Them in leather craftsman that has used Bick 4 - leather conditioner high... Agree, you agree to our use of cookies has added some very unique dimensions the... Bad to feeling good compares to saphir Medaille d'Or Renovateur instead of.... Color from your shoe cream and Venetian leather Balm out looking better than I expected those in... It felt like normal darkening long time, they must know what they doing... During the summer same shoe creme to use after using Bick 4 is formulated to.... Each conditioner super popular for shoe care does both, I was surprised how little stuff left!